If we encounter intelligent aliens, will they turn out to lack self-awareness? [read description] | Manifold

If we encounter intelligent aliens, will they turn out to lack self-awareness? [read description]

Mini

4

Ṁ89

9999

38%

chance

1D

1W

1M

ALL

Intelligent = capable of sending signals across space or capable of spaceflight.

Aliens = another civilization or artificial constructs created by another civilization.

If we encounter aliens, will their behavior indicate that they are effectively highly intelligent "Chinese Rooms"? (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room) or [SPOILER ALERT] resemble something similar to "Scramblers" from the novel "Blindsight" by Peter Watts (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blindsight_(Watts_novel)). Scramblers lacked self-awareness and didn't have internal "conscious experiences". The premise of the novel was that intelligence is independent of consciousness.

Resolves to YES when the general scientific consensus is that at least 50% of encountered alien specimens/technological alien signatures (i.e., radio signals) indicate 'Scrambler-similar' aliens.

Resolves to NO otherwise.

Due to slightly subjective resolution criteria I will not bet on this market

Get

1,000

and

1.00

Sort by:

bought Ṁ2 NO

This is a really interesting question, the best kind of thing to find on Manifold

Related questions

When we first meet (intelligent, advanced) aliens, will they value increasing happiness and reducing suffering of all sentient life forms?

Will the first intelligent extraterrestrial that humanity encounters have what would be commonly described as eyes?

What biological characteristics will the first proven aliens have?

Will we detect extraterrestrial intelligent life in the universe by 2124?

Conditional on strong evidence of aliens being discovered, will they have DNA?

P(Aliens) - Is there human-level or above intelligent life in the Milky Way?

Will super intelligent AI instantly become empathetic towards humans even though we put no effort into aligning it?

First confirmed intelligent aliens will be

If intelligent aliens visit us, will AI-based technologies outperform analog linguistics in translating their language?

Will humanity detect evidence of an extraterrestrial intelligence before the year 2100?

Related questions

When we first meet (intelligent, advanced) aliens, will they value increasing happiness and reducing suffering of all sentient life forms?

P(Aliens) - Is there human-level or above intelligent life in the Milky Way?

Will the first intelligent extraterrestrial that humanity encounters have what would be commonly described as eyes?

Will super intelligent AI instantly become empathetic towards humans even though we put no effort into aligning it?

What biological characteristics will the first proven aliens have?

First confirmed intelligent aliens will be

Will we detect extraterrestrial intelligent life in the universe by 2124?

If intelligent aliens visit us, will AI-based technologies outperform analog linguistics in translating their language?

Conditional on strong evidence of aliens being discovered, will they have DNA?

Will humanity detect evidence of an extraterrestrial intelligence before the year 2100?

Terms & Conditions•Privacy Policy•Sweepstakes Rules