These are 40 of the top prospects for the 2024 NFL draft. At the end of the 2024-25 NFL season, I will randomly pair off each of these players with another and make 20 polls asking "Who was a more valuable draft selection, [Player X] or [Player Y]?" All players who win their poll resolve YES, all players who lose their poll resolve NO.

If a player misses 13+ games due to injury they will be resolved N/A. If an odd number of players get resolved N/A, the player who misses the next most games due to injury will be resolved N/A as well.